> ## Content Index > Fetch the complete content index at: https://blog.dgactual.com/llms.txt > Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further. # Same Consumer, Three Outcomes - URL: https://blog.dgactual.com/same-consumer-three-outcomes/ - Published: 2026-09-24T14:48:13.000Z - Updated: 2026-09-24T14:48:13.000Z - Description: Wendy's is closing stores and its biggest franchisee just filed for bankruptcy. Burger King and Cava grew in the same quarter. Everyone blames the delivery apps. The drive-thru data has a better suspect. - Author: Daniel - Tags: Signal Analysis, Market Intelligence **Wendy's is closing stores and its biggest franchisee just filed for bankruptcy. Burger King and Cava grew in the same quarter, selling to the same shopper at the same beef prices. Everyone blames the delivery apps. The drive-thru data has a better suspect.** By Daniel Govaer | DGactual Signal Analysis | September 2026 Picture one American at 7:40 on a Tuesday morning, gas back over four dollars, coffee not yet acquired. In the second quarter of 2026 that person, multiplied by a couple hundred million, handed three fast-food brands three completely different report cards. Wendy's: US same-restaurant sales down 7.0%, traffic down 12.5%, 289 restaurants closed in six months, dividend cut in half, guidance withdrawn. Burger King: US comps up 8.5%. Cava: sales up 9%, traffic up 5.3%. Then on September 17, Meritage Hospitality Group, which runs 314 Wendy's (about 5.5% of the US system), filed for Chapter 11. (Quick translator for anyone who doesn't read earnings calls for fun: "comp" or "same-restaurant sales" means sales at stores open more than a year, so new openings and closures don't flatter or punish the number. "Traffic" is the count of orders. When comps fall less than traffic, the store is charging more per bag.) The popular explanation for the Wendy's half of this story is tidy. Wendy's lives and dies by the drive-thru. The drive-thru is shrinking. It's shrinking because DoorDash and Uber Eats moved the convenience trip from the lane to the phone. Wendy's was standing in the wrong channel when the tide went out. We spent two weeks running that theory against every 2025 and 2026 dataset we could get our hands on. The first two links hold up fine. The third one falls apart, and what replaces it says more about how Wendy's ran its restaurants than any app ever could. ## **Wendy's exposure** Start with what's true. Burger chains have long pushed about 70% of sales through the lane. Wendy's doesn't disclose its own mix, but when new CEO Bob Wright diagnosed the quarter, he started there: "Drive-thru is a good example, where we need to better manage peak hour traffic, ensure restaurants are staffed appropriately for demand, and equip teams with training, tools, and systems they need to deliver consistently." Translation: the cars showed up and the crew wasn't ready. The digital side is thinner still. Wendy's digital mix (the share of sales placed on a screen instead of at a speaker or counter) was 22.7% in Q1 2026\. Chipotle is at 38.3%, Cava at 39.0%, Taco Bell at 47%. Wendy's loyalty program had 46 million members as of early 2025, and the company hasn't updated that number since. On the Q2 call Wright listed "our customer loyalty approach, along with the integration with third-party aggregators" as opportunities. Chipotle and Cava treated those as table stakes four years ago. So the exposure is real and the CEO says so out loud. The question is what, exactly, the lane is exposed to. ## **The stat everyone quotes, and where it starts counting** The number that launched a thousand LinkedIn posts comes from Revenue Management Solutions: drive-thru fell from 83% of fast-food orders in 2020 to 65% in 2025\. Eighteen points. Real. Also measured from the one year in modern history when dining rooms were closed by government order. Intouch Insight's mystery shoppers counted an average of 1.20 cars in line in 2025, versus 1.23 in 2024 and more than 2 in 2020\. A lane that carried the entire business in 2020 was always going to hand some of it back when the doors reopened. That's a hangover, not a heist. Measure from a normal year instead and the whole picture flips. Circana's CREST panel, published through the National Restaurant Association, tracks how limited-service traffic splits by channel. Here's 2019 against 2024: | Channel | 2019 | 2024 | Change | | ----------------------------- | ---- | ---- | ----------- | | Drive-thru | 41% | 43% | +2 pts | | Takeout (incl. mobile pickup) | 31% | 31% | 0 | | Delivery | 4% | 9% | +5 pts | | Off-premises total | 76% | 83% | +7 pts | | On-premises (implied) | 24% | 17% | minus 7 pts | Delivery gained five points. The dining room lost seven. The drive-thru gained two. Over the five years that matter, the app ate the dining room and the lane came out ahead. If delivery were cannibalizing the drive-thru, this is the table where the bite marks would be, and they're on the other side of the building. ## **What went wrong after 2024** Then 2024 happens and the lane starts losing, and this is the part that gives the delivery theory its oxygen. RMS's client data for Q2 2025 versus Q2 2024: takeout up 15.5%, delivery up 13.5%, dine-in up 1.2%, drive-thru down 5.8%. QSR Magazine's 2025 Drive-Thru Report found drive-thru traffic negative every single month from January 2024 through June 2025\. Everything grew except the lane. Case closed, right? Look at when the lane is losing. RMS has breakfast traffic down 9.5% in Q1 2025 and averaging minus 8.0% for the year. Breakfast is the most drive-thru-dependent hour in fast food and the one nobody orders through an app. When RMS ran 14.6 billion fast-food transactions against pump prices, it found a 10% jump in gas trims visits by 0.6% to 1.2%, the damage gets steeper above $4 a gallon, and the stores that hurt most are the ones built on commuters, impulse stops and drive-thru convenience. Placer.ai's phone-location data for April and May 2026 shows sub-10-minute fast-food visits falling sharply while 10-to-30-minute visits gained share, which Placer reads as people parking and eating instead of idling in line. Gas went back above $4 in August. RMS had fast-food traffic down 3.5% that month. Consumers' own plans point the same direction. In RMS's Q1 2026 survey of 841 people, roughly three-quarters use the drive-thru weekly, three-quarters use dine-in weekly, and about half use delivery weekly. Asked about the year ahead, 40% said they'd cut delivery against 11% planning more, while 34% planned more dine-in against 16% planning less. Trade write-ups of that survey render the exact figures a little differently, so call them approximate. Every version has the same shape: delivery is the channel people say they're trimming. ## **The app and the lane are on different shifts** If delivery were stealing drive-thru trips, it would be strongest where the lane is weakest. It's the reverse. PAR Technology's 2025 data from more than 30,000 fast-food restaurants puts the average third-party delivery check at $22.73, 61% above the roughly $14 all-channel average. The delivery markup is largest at breakfast, 78%, which is what happens when almost nobody orders breakfast through an app and the few who do are ordering for the whole office. Delivery's real volume is dinner ($24.76 average check) and late night ($16.43). The lane bleeds at 7:40 a.m. The app feasts at 7:40 p.m. Those are different trips made by different versions of the same person. Price explains why they rarely overlap. RMS's June 2026 release ran the math on a $10.29 combo: after app markup, fees and tip it comes out to $27.37\. Nobody who wants a ten-dollar breakfast sandwich is weighing a twenty-seven-dollar alternative. The one direct substitution study on record, Medallia's April 2023 survey of 2,016 people, found about 37% of third-party users would otherwise have gotten the same food by dining in or picking up, and about 41% would have cooked or skipped the meal. That's the strongest evidence for cannibalization anyone has produced, it lumps the drive-thru in with the dining room, and it's three years old. Nobody has asked the drive-thru version since. Meanwhile delivery keeps growing. DoorDash's Q2 2026 revenue rose 24% year over year excluding its Deliveroo acquisition, orders up 17%. That volume is coming from somewhere. The census-grade data says: the dining room, and the meal that used to get cooked at home. ## **Three brands, one lane, three plays** Here's where it gets interesting, because Burger King and Cava sell to the exact same gas-squeezed, value-hunting person, and both of them grew. **Burger King fixed the building.** Its 2026 franchise disclosure document (the FDD, the annual filing where a franchisor has to tell prospective operators what the stores actually earn), as reported by QSR Magazine, shows full remodels lifting sales 11.9% on average, tear-down-and-rebuilds 26%, and conversions to a double drive-thru 16.8%. The flagship Sizzle design runs 14.9%. Just over half the US system is now in a modern image, headed for 85% by 2028, with menu pricing held to low single digits and $5 Duos and $7 Trios as the everyday floor. Burger King made the lane faster and the dining room worth walking into in the same remodel, and took the No. 2 burger spot from Wendy's along the way. **Cava built for people who sit down.** Dine-in was already 64% of Cava's orders when it launched Project Soul in 2024, a refresh of seating, lighting and color designed to make you want to stay; every 2026 opening has it. Cava runs a 39.0% digital mix, took one 1.4% price increase in January 2026 while holding the base bowl flat, and prices its delivery menu to cover the commission, which still cost it 40 basis points of operating expense in Q2\. Traffic rose 5.3%. Its third-party delivery mix rose year over year but fell from Q1 to Q2, which is what you'd expect if customers are trimming the app and walking in. **Wendy's closed buildings.** The 289 first-half closures are Project Fresh, a plan to remove 5 to 6% of the US system. Its largest franchisee's first profit move was to exit or shorten breakfast at roughly 120 locations, which Meritage says added more than $11 million of store-level profit right away. Meritage's own account of what went wrong: beef up nearly 19% year over year, "deep discounting and national promotional strategies at the brand level" that gave away margin without holding traffic, and weaker marketing under prior leadership, with store-level EBITDA down 48% in 2025\. Wendy's then pulled back on discounting, which lifted check 5.6%, held the comp to minus 7.0%, and, by the company's own account, pushed traffic down further. One line from the Q2 call deserved more attention than it got: company-operated Wendy's beat the franchised system by 280 basis points on same-restaurant sales. Same brand, same menu, same lane. The stores with corporate capital and corporate staffing did better. | | Wendy's | Burger King | Cava | | --------------- | --------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | | Q2 2026 US comp | minus 7.0% | +8.5% | +9.0% | | Traffic | minus 12.5% | not disclosed | +5.3% | | Digital mix | 22.7% (Q1) | not disclosed | 39.0% | | The building | 289 closures in H1; breakfast exits | Remodels lifting 12% to 26%; 85% modern by 2028 | Project Soul refresh; dine-in led | | Pricing | Check +5.6% after Biggie Deals | Low single digits; value bundles | 1.4% once; base bowl flat | | Delivery | Aggregator integration "an opportunity" | Not disclosed | Priced to cover commission; 40 bp opex hit | ## **The better thesis** Delivery ate the dining room first. From 2019 to 2024 the app took five points of share, the dining room gave up seven, and the lane held. Since 2024 the drive-thru has been losing frequency, not to a rival channel but to fewer trips, and the losses pile up at breakfast and among commuters. The competition for those trips is the kitchen at home, the c-store on the corner (Circana has c-store foodservice traffic positive for the first time in nine quarters), and the mobile-order pickup shelf inside the restaurant, where takeout grew faster than delivery did. Gas above $4 and a value menu that stopped feeling like value did more damage to the lane than any app. That reframes Wendy's. The lane no longer delivers traffic by default, so the building has to be worth visiting on purpose and the crew has to be ready when the cars come. Burger King rebuilt the building and got a double-digit lift per store. Cava designed the building for people who want to sit, which is where the census data says the recovery is happening. Wendy's ran the most lane-dependent system in the category with the thinnest digital layer, discounted its way into a margin crisis, raised check into a traffic decline, and closed the stores that couldn't take it. The delivery apps were in the parking lot the whole time, minding their own business. Wright put it better than he probably meant to: "Every single experience ends analog, not digital." The analog part is the building, the crew and the lane. That's the part Wendy's has to fix. ## **What would change our mind** A Circana or Technomic cut of lost drive-thru occasions by daypart and party size, matched against delivery growth, for 2024 through 2026\. Or a brand that reports both channels (Chipotle, with Chipotlanes on 80% of new units and a 38% digital mix, is the cleanest natural experiment) showing solo dinner trips migrating from the lane to the app. If either shows up, the delivery theory earns a narrow, defensible version. Until then it's a hunch with a great headline. ## **How we sourced this** None of these is a true census, and the differences matter. | Source | What it is | Freshness | Limits | | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Circana CREST via NRA | Consumer panel projected to the US population, the closest thing to a census | 2024 annual shares; quarterly traffic through Q4 2025 | No drive-thru figure in 2025-2026 releases | | Revenue Management Solutions | Client transaction data, client count not disclosed | Through August 2026 | 2020 baseline; client mix unknown | | PAR Technology | Client point-of-sale data, 30,000+ QSR units | Full-year 2025 | PAR clients only | | Placer.ai | Device location panel, visits by dwell time | May 2026 | Sub-10-minute bucket includes pickup and delivery drivers, can't isolate the lane | | Intouch Insight / QSR Magazine | 2,265 mystery shops, 13 brands | June to July 2025 | Attributing lost traffic to delivery is the authors' read, not a measurement | | Medallia | Consumer survey, N=2,016 | April 2023, stale | Doesn't separate drive-thru from dine-in | | Burger King FDD via QSR Magazine | Franchisor disclosure of remodeled-unit sales lifts | 2026 FDD | Self-reported; remodel candidates aren't random | | Company filings and calls | Wendy's, Restaurant Brands, Cava, Chipotle, Yum, McDonald's, DoorDash, Meritage | Q2 2026 | Digital-mix definitions differ by brand; nobody discloses delivery versus drive-thru volume | Every delta, share and ratio here was computed in code and reconciled two ways before publishing, including the implied on-premises share, the Wendy's traffic-and-check math (which lands within 0.6 points of the reported comp), the unit-count math and Meritage's share of the system. The person skipping the breakfast lane over gas prices is the same one walking into a dealership this fall. For the vehicle side of that story, the DGactual Automotive Retail Price Index updates weekly at [data.dgactual.com](https://data.dgactual.com/?ref=blog.dgactual.com), and the Dealer Reputation Scoreboard lives at [reviews.dgactual.com](https://reviews.dgactual.com/?ref=blog.dgactual.com). **Sources:** The Wendy's Company, Q2 2026 results (https://www.irwendys.com/news/news-details/2026/THE-WENDYS-COMPANY-REPORTS-SECOND-QUARTER-2026-RESULTS/default.aspx) and earnings call (https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/WEN/earnings/WEN-Q2-2026-earnings\_call-663910.html/); Restaurant Dive on Wendy's loyalty, February 2025 (https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/wendys-invests-chicken-beverages-value-breakfast-menu-2025/740046/); Meritage Hospitality Group, Chapter 11 release (https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2026/09/17/3364435/34866/en/meritage-initiates-voluntary-chapter-11-process-to-strengthen-its-balance-sheet-and-position-the-company-for-long-term-success.html); Restaurant Dive on Meritage (https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/wendys-franchisee-meritage-hospitality-group-files-chapter-11-bankruptcy/830750/); Yahoo Finance on Meritage (https://finance.yahoo.com/small-business/articles/meritage-hospitality-group-files-chapter-114934454.html); Restaurant Brands International Q2 2026 call (https://www.fool.com/earnings/call-transcripts/2026/08/13/restaurant-brands-qsr-q2-2026-earnings-call-transcript/); QSR Magazine on Burger King's 2026 FDD remodel lifts (https://www.qsrmagazine.com/story/can-burger-king-sustain-momentum-it-starts-with-whats-still-left-to-do/); Restaurant Dive on Burger King remodels (https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/burger-king-remodels-refranchising-carrols-drive-sales-franchisee-profits/739996/); Cava Q2 2026 call (https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/markets/stocks/CAVA/pressreleases/3918016/cava-cava-q2-2026-earnings-call-transcript/); Restaurant Dive on Cava Project Soul, February 2024 (https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/cava-wants-more-dine-in-traffic-grew-revenue-60-percent-in-2023/708743/) and Q1 2026 (https://www.restaurantdive.com/news/cava-wins-q1-with-97-same-store-sales-jump/820630/); Restaurant Business on Cava pricing (https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/operations/cava-proves-keeping-menu-prices-down-can-drive-traffic-without-harming-margins); Chipotle Q2 2026 call (https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/C9F.MU/earnings/C9F.MU-Q2-2026-earnings\_call-657322.html); Yum Brands Q2 2026 call (https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/YUM.MX/earnings/YUM.MX-Q2-2026-earnings\_call-656906.html); DoorDash Q2 2026 results (https://ir.doordash.com/news/news-details/2026/DoorDash-Releases-Second-Quarter-2026-Financial-Results/default.aspx); National Restaurant Association / Circana, Restaurant Off-Premises Report 2025 (https://www.ncrla.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/Restaurant-OffPremises-Report.pdf); Circana, State of the Industry deck, February 2026 (https://www.cdaweb.net/Portals/0/MarketPlace/2026/Education/Circana%20State%20of%20the%20Industry%20and%20Consumer%20Behaviors%20-%20Marketplace%202026.pdf); Circana Q1 2026 update via Robert Rhee, LinkedIn (https://www.linkedin.com/posts/robertrhee128\_qsr-restaurantindustry-foodservice-activity-7485721182940463104-jTdh); Revenue Management Solutions, Drive-Thru Trends 2025 (https://www.revenuemanage.com/blog/drive-thru-trends-2025-qsr/), Q1 2025 trends (https://www.revenuemanage.com/trends/restaurant-trends-q1-2025/), gas price study, March 2026 (https://www.revenuemanage.com/blog/gas-prices-drive-thru-impact/), September 2026 trends (https://www.revenuemanage.com/trends/restaurant-trends-september-2026/), June 2026 release via GlobeNewswire (https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2026/06/16/3312537/0/en/qsr-still-wins-on-value-as-consumer-ordering-habits-change-the-equation.html); RMS Q1 2026 consumer survey via Franchising.com (https://www.franchising.com/amp/articles/20260408\_report\_3\_forces\_reshaping\_restaurant\_demand\_in\_2026.html) and FSR Magazine (https://www.fsrmagazine.com/feature/nearly-half-of-full-service-diners-cut-back-visits-study-finds/); Modern Restaurant Management, QSR Halftime Report (https://modernrestaurantmanagement.com/qsr-halftime-report-value-and-channel-strategies-to-finish-strong-in-2025/); QSR Magazine, 2025 Drive-Thru Report (https://www.qsrmagazine.com/story/the-2025-qsr-drive-thru-report/) and 2026 QSR 50 (https://www.qsrmagazine.com/story/the-2026-qsr-50-fast-foods-leading-annual-report/); Intouch Insight, 2025 Drive-Thru Study (https://www.intouchinsight.com/press-releases/drive-thru-study-2025-press-release; https://www.intouchinsight.com/blog/qsr-drive-thru-customer-behavior); PAR Technology, 2026 QSR Operational Index (https://partech.com/press-releases/par-technology-releases-2026-qsr-operational-index-report-highlighting-loyalty-digital-channels-and-revenue-trends-across-u-s/); Placer.ai Dining Index, April 2026 (https://www.placer.ai/anchor/articles/april-2026-placer-ai-dining-index-is-the-price-at-the-pump-impacting-drive-thru-visits) and May 2026 (https://www.placer.ai/anchor/articles/may-2026-placer-ai-dining-index-is-drive-thru-traffic-running-out-of-gas); Medallia, The State of Third-Party Delivery, 2023 (https://www.medallia.com/wp-content/uploads/pdf/resources/Medallia-The-State-of-Third-Party-Delivery-Slides.pdf). Research and data reconciliation support: Perplexity Computer.